gojete
I have won 13 wars in a row, I have been a successful monarch of a successful kingdom.
The number of actual elite players in the game is substantially lower these days than it was a few calendar years ago. That said, there still are a bunch of us out here. And having played this game since its earliest ages, I have to tell you a building strat that heavy on homes isn't going to work when you run into real experienced and competent players. It has nothing to do with math or even spreadsheets. While they are the basic gravity of Utopia, knowing what to do, why to do it, and when to do it as a player in a competent kingdom is what makes taking apart a 50% homes province a fairly simple process. It would be harder to dismantle a total noobie rainbow strat province than it would be to take apart the 50% homes province.
A lot of the best players arent even in superkingdoms or alliance kingdoms these days and arent even trying to get to the top of the charts. We are all in our 30's & 40's now with real lives and real concerns. Yet we keep playing Utopia because of the bonds in the game that have been forged over years. Heck last age we had more babies born in our kingdom than wars were fought and we still wound up in the top 50 for both land and networth. Could we do better? Yep we sure could. A lot of the "top" kingdoms are literally just very dedicated players lead by some decent monarchs. They benefit from the fact that many players are no where near as good as the average players from half a decade ago. Bring back that talent pool today and you would be utterly destroyed if you played a 50% homes strat.
Back in the day, there were a few Ages where people attempted to have really high home builds. And they got slaughtered. What people learned in the aftermath of those ages was that just because it looks good in a simulator or on a spread sheet, it doesn't work in real time on Utopia. Can you get away with that strat today? Possibly. But that has more to do with the current average skill level of the players. If you ran into a kingdom made up of veterans who have forgotten more about Utopia than you have even learned, you would more than likely get a first hand experience as to why you DON'T run 50% homes.
Your stance on this theory regarding homes is similar to our kingdom's current war where a noob ghetto running all attackers with limited t/m capacity mistakenly decided to war with us. They are currently learning why running a 0.5 WPA & 0.5 TPA as a kingdom strat is suicidal against a mix of veteran uber geeks that play with a very high coordination and use an entire resource pool to grind them into the dirt. Even though they were certain of victory at the start and were boasting how much they were destroying us. It is to there misfortune that almost all our players have been playing since the earliest ages of Utopia. most of us have been playing since Age 4.
So I wish you good luck in running your 50% homes strategy and hope that you don't blunder into a kingdom like mine where we already know how to tear a province like yours apart because we learned how to around Age 12.