Quote:
That's what you've said in the other thread. My system is similar, you've got max gains that are based on your honor (not the opponents), and it is being modified by honor difference first, then nw difference and kd nw difference.
But I haven't thought of how to change the honor gained from ops. I think there should be a minimum honor gained from ops in times of war. But I don't think it should be fixed, like taking 10 points for MS, it would affect a knight more than a baron. I think that ops should take honor in relation to how much both provinces have. So a baron casting on a baron would get more than a baron casting on a knight or a knight casting on a baron.
Okay. From what I read of your initial post, all you really did was change the base value from your opponent's honor to your own honor. This is a pointless change, as under your system a baron attacking a knight would gain significantly more honor than the same knight attacking the baron. That doesn't fix the problem that the attack isn't harder for the baron to get off. If anything, it's a little easier. Your change would make it easy for provinces to get to prince; all they would have to do is T/M to baron, then convert to attacker and bottomfeed. The more honor you have, the more you would gain.