It's about that time....rate my gnome

[trefnwyd]

Well, I've played utopia for years but I've never had constructive criticism on my prov from the forums. There's always a first time for everything :) I'm smallish to stay within kingdom range. Obviously the leets are used for offense too...

All-in-One Formatted Report

The Province of XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX (XX:XX)
[http://www.UtopiaTemple.com All-in-One v4.23b]

Server:
Utopian Date: May 4th, YR8
RL Date: December 6th, 2008 (4:00 GMT)

Ruler Name: Blah........... the Rogue
Personality & Race: The Rogue, Gnome
Land: 3,3XX Acres
Money: 194gc (54,052gc raw daily income)
Food: 101,651 bushels
Runes: 135,567 runes
Population: 108,435 citizens (32.72 per Acre)
Peasants: 27,026 (87% Building Efficiency)
Trade Balance: 7,504,819gc

Military Eff. with Stance: 130.9% off. / 130% def.
Soldiers: 626 (626 offense and defense)
Halflings: 16,XXX (80,535 offense points)
Pikemen: 19,XXX (96,625 defense points)
Golems: 27,XXX (136,955 offense and defense)
War-Horses: 13,XXX (up to 13,452 additional offense)
Prisoners: 1,XXX

Total Modified Offense: 303,195 (91.49 per Acre)
Practical (0% elites): 123,848 (37.37 per Acre)
Total Modified Defense: 304,507 (91.89 per Acre)
Practical (100% elites): 304,507 (91.89 per Acre)

Thieves: 13,670 (4.12 per Acre / XX% Stealth)
Rogue Defense TPA: 4.95 per Acre
MOD TPA: 15.04
Wizards: 4,290 (1.29 per Acre / XX% Mana)

Buildings: 1,986gc to build, 1,179gc to raze
Away bonus: 135,130gc (12h) / 405,390gc (20h)

---------------------------------------------------------
Science Intelligence on XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
[http://www.UtopiaTemple.com All-in-One v4.23b]

Server: World of Legends (Age 36)

** Effects Summary (Known Science Only) **
+17.5% Income (518,685 points)
+11.7% Building Effectiveness (454,052 points)
+6.9% Population Limits (369,082 points)
+35.7% Food Production (100,240 points)
+7.1% Combat Gains (107,888 points)
+80% Thievery Effectiveness (588,631 points)
+39.8% Magic Effectiveness (210,058 points)

** Science Points in Progress **
Crime: 14,556 points in progress

[trefnwyd]

I have a few extra guilds (taken out of rax) because I may be facing a few same-sized DEs next in an upcoming war.


Buildings Report of [SELF]
[http://www.UtopiaTemple.com All-in-One v4.23b]

Server: World of Legends (Age 36)
Ruler Name: XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX
Building Efficiency: %

1. Barren Lands: 21 (0.6%)
2. Homes: 294 (8.9%)
3. Farms: 253 (7.6%)
4. Banks: 340 (10.3%)
5. Training Grounds: 364 (11%)
6. Barracks: 180 (5.4%)
7. Forts: 336 (10.1%)
8. Guilds: 513 (15.5%)
9. Towers: 186 (5.6%)
10. Thieves' Dens: 531 (16%)
11. Stables: 225 (6.8%)
12. Dungeons: 71 (2.1%)

Total Land: 3,314 Acres (99.4% built)

[AFKain]

Replacing some intel with Xs just looks silly, especially when you post the information in other places or information to calculate the hidden numbers... There's no reason to hide troops, it's just annoying for a reader. You might want to remove the location from the science report though.

Prov looks good to me.
Build: you have too much resource buildings imo, lower towers and farms, gnomes can get their resources in other places easily. Too few TGs.

[_greenie]

Rogue Defense TPA: 4.95 per Acre

get a better formatter =)
its hard to tell what practical opa/dpa number are =)

[vines]

Seems like a well ran province, however, That's is not the build you are using. If you are going to post strategies post what you are using. Other wise you're strategy does not help any one. And if it doesn't help any one there is no point in posting. Put up the real build that you are using.

[AFKain]

The build posted is the build he uses, that he has changed the build slightly from what he would use in war is irrelevant, builds change to fit the current needs and you have been informed of how the build would be in war. His intention isn't to help anyone, he wanted feedback on his province.

[vines]

So gave us the build that he is no longer using but the stats of the build that he currently is using. Umm he doesn't want to help people but he wants people to help him? Is that what you just said.

[Leshrak]

So gave us the build that he is no longer using but the stats of the build that he currently is using. Umm he doesn't want to help people but he wants people to help him? Is that what you just said.

Yes. That's what the OP said in his initial post. He wants feedback and opinions on his province.

[vines]

No no you are misunderstand what I'm saying his build is much different than the build he posted up. I can tell by the number he posted up from his cb. If is not going to shoot straight with us there is not much we can do about that. Leshrak do not defend a person that tries do trick people.

[insane33]

Very nice prov, i dont think you can make it better looking.

[Dolgil]

vines, he would get that pop per acre being a baron.

[_greenie]

he would get that pop/acre without baron and homes =)

[Someone]

I think its looking good. Raise wpa slightly? ->1.5-2 wpa, maybe?

[trefnwyd]

When I posted my CB I was viscount, which explains the population. Vines, I did not change anything or try to make my province look better in any way. That would defeat the purpose of asking for constructive criticism...

Thanks for the feedback guys. I'm propping up my wpa now. I'll stop once I have 2 mod wpa.

[Ishandra]

I like it :)