Thanks everyone for your input.

This isn't my province, but it is a province in my KD. The arguements presented are also belongs to the province in question - copy/pasted here, to create some input.
We had a long discussion around this on the KD forums, without getting anywhere.
He would find "evidence" of his style of play being common/best by SoT'ing equally sized halfers and Faeries, while dismissing SoT's taken from warring KD's with high offense as random provinces found to support my own theories. Pointers to, and calculations of buildings/wpa/tpa and Off/Def ratio's were shrugged off as "bad advice".


We just got out of war now, perhaps time to show him that our opinions and strategic advice is common thinking around the Utopian community, rather than us being a'holes giving him a hard time.