Page 26 of 55 FirstFirst ... 16242526272836 ... LastLast
Results 376 to 390 of 815

Thread: New Anticheat Measure Going Live Today

  1. #376
    Newbie
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    4
    Quote Originally Posted by Gallowmere View Post
    Well, since I am not a dev or mod, and am free to voice my opinion without worrying about my wording bothering someone too much:

    This is not Fascism, this is not a democracy, this is not a republic...this is a privately run company that hosts a game that we all play.

    Since (from what I understand), the game already costs the devs money to run, it's obviously not turning a profit. As such, deal with how they decide to handle things, or shut the **** up and leave. That simple. The sooner all of the whiners leave, the closer the devs are to being able to close the game down with minimal disappointment, and stop losing money. If that's not what you want to see happen, suck it up and adjust.
    Obviously you're not a paying customer here then. Some people however, have paid. Some people have paid a LOT. When someone pays for a service, then that service changes on them, they have every single right to complain. And normally, customer service would attempt to resolve those complaints. I really hate that line "shut up and leave" - people have paid money. It's not their fault if the current plans don't turn a profit.

    Moving along...

    I idle in a KD's irc channel who so happens to have a married couple. Only one. In their channel, when the changes first popped out - they were in a pump. I asked them what they felt, and the said "it sorta sucks, since we never xlog for each other, but we don't really have any contact with the same provinces, so I doubt it will really affect us" - exactly what DHaran and Bishop have been saying - their "research" was correct it seems. Most married couples won't experience too big of an issue.............. Today, their KD just got waved. Now it's almost comical to watch the realization that not having any same-province contact for 72 hours is a huge disadvantage to planning their war. I'm watching them pre-war decided what targets the TM isn't allowed to OP and which targets the attacker isn't allowed to attack.

    Ok. To play devil's advocate for a quick second, I'll admit that the whitelist gave people the ability to xlog. Yes, this could be an advantage, but.. was it REALLY that BIG of advantage? With the ability to use cell phones, and most KD's idling in irc, and mates texting each other.. MOST of the advantages it would have had 40 ages ago are nil. Sure, they do experience *some slight* advantage, but it's obviously not THAT much, or the Top 10 KD's would each have 2 or 3 or 4 whitelisted couples... The top 100 provinces would be a majority of whitelisted couples... So on and so on.

    Now, with this change, and after watching this KD plan their pre-war strategies, its quite obvious that sure - they're going to get around it... but at a *huge* disadvantage. If the TM gathers intel on someone who becomes a chain target 48 hours later, the attacker cant chain. I could go on and on about all the scenarios already discussed 100 times in this thread... but now I'm watching them actually unfold and it's ridiculous the careful planning that has to go into just making sure they can both participate so they're not down another province.

    I understand you're trying to eliminate cheating, but the cheating you've eliminated by this wasn't causing a stupid advantage. You're not going to be able to multi GB a province with 2 friggen provinces. And if 3+ accounts shared the same IP. I'd hope that would be investigated rather quickly and shut down before they even got OOP. What's really funny is that it keeps being repeated here that it was unfair because a whitelisted couple could log for each other. Tell me how this change prevents that? They can still log for each other as often as they want. Just don't interact. So it's still an advantage. All that was done is that people can't perform their roles.

    And just a little quote from their IRC room, obviously edited for anonymity:

    [10:32] <~XXXXXXX> Its not an issue of wether or not I can get intel or MS coverage from another T/M, the issue is that I now can not 'freely' chain targets. Essentially one of my provinces (in this case the halfer) is being hobbled an forced to attack provinces low on the food chain (s**t gains) and is going to be using his 6tpa to steal gold/runes from fearies/elvees instead of NSing our chain targets.
    [10:35] <~XXXXXXX> Had I known of this earlier I would have had him come in as an attacker an planned on him staying small just to pick on the lower end of the food chain. I now have to totally revamp his an her strats to accomadate the changes.

  2. #377
    Post Fiend ElusiveWitch's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2011
    Posts
    118
    *sighs*

    I totally take back the post I made several pages ago. This is doing nothing but hampering people. It isn't stopping cheating. Cheaters already know how to work around it. Course I did say that in the original post.

    Now that we are in/going to war - I've really had my eyes opened on what I thought would be something easy to resolve and work around. It's not. And the emotional posts that I thought were putting the cart before the horse were actually right.

    BTW - Hi Lirath!! ;)

  3. #378
    Moderator for:
    Utopia Forums
    Palem's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    22,030
    @Nuriho - Cheaters are deleted. Have you been deleted? Then you're not a cheater.

    @ Shadow27 - I agree, the time frame on the block makes or breaks this system and I agree that 3 days is too long. Luckily the devs aren't blind, deaf, and dumb to the community (despite what you may hear) and are open to suggestions on how to make it work. I've already put forth my suggestion but I haven't seen too many people follow suit.

    Quote Originally Posted by Drop Dead Sexy (DDS) View Post
    So either the whitelist exists or you delete them all. right?
    This is incorrect and has already been discussed/explained by Bishop, DHaran, and myself.

  4. #379
    Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    18
    Palem - Please look at reply #362 and tell me if remark #2 is possible. I would say it would level the playing field as you wish, but it will still make warring achievable with my wife in the same kingdom.

    Thank you.

  5. #380
    Moderator for:
    Utopia Forums
    Palem's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    22,030
    Yes, I think that's possible. That actually lines up perfectly with my suggestion
    Normal = 3 days
    Unfriendly = 2 days
    Hostile = 1 day
    War = 12 hours?
    However, my opinion matters just as much as yours in this, so we'll see.

  6. #381
    Member
    Join Date
    Jul 2011
    Posts
    18
    Thank you. I think this is very much a possibility. I understand the mods wanting to put this system in place, so instead of fighting it like everyone else. I am directly affected by this so I was thinking of solutions so my wife and I can still play in the same kingdom. 12 hours would be perfect for war, then I dont have to look 5 days down the road and predict who she is going to hit. I dont know any mods or have any ins with this game as you may do, you opinion may matter more than mine, I hope you can bring this to the proper people and they can take a real hard look at it.


    Thank you.

    Rob and Nancy from Wanna Play!

  7. #382
    Post Fiend
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Posts
    109
    Quote Originally Posted by DDodge View Post
    two people playing in the same household is a massive advantage, and easily abused. Go home, log your account, log your "spouses" account, and you can coordinate anything you need perfectly.

    its a team game, and yes top KDs will instantaneously contact each other, but thats the whole point of the game. playing two accounts from your IP is pretty sketchy/ab-usable.

    before you respond that YOU personally only play your account and your significant other only plays theirs, please acknowledge the fact that any couple whitelisted CAN x-log each other with no penalty under the old system. If you have a better way to stop this from happening please share. Whitelisting has been a "get out of jail free" pass for couples to x-log for each other if the other even has work or an appointment or w/e. Its been abused massively.

    Yeah so you just prove its turning into a "PAY TO WIN" game since you are allowed SITTING. Just because you pay money its ok now huh?

  8. #383
    Newbie
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    4
    Oh, and since my entire post of pointing out how this system is just wrong didn't include a suggestion, I'll add to it.

    Obviously, no matter how much we talk about how this system is somewhat silly from the ground up. Knowing that this will effectively block the most minimal forms of cheating and advantages. Real cheating will circumvent this no problem. (I'm sorry, but logging on your wife's account to get that SoT is soooooooooooo not a big advantage.... having multis and farms all over the place to GB provinces is the real advantage, and that will continue.. people aren't too stupid about it).

    But, if everyone is convinced this actually deals with cheating and curbs the enormous advantage that whitelisted people have... then here is my suggestion. Make the ban on ops 4 hours TOPS. If you can't have a KD mate hit a province, op a province, aid you, or get an SoT for you in 4 hours - then I don't care what kind of advantage you have, it's not gonna matter. 4 hours is more than plenty of time to prevent the instantaneous benefit that one could possibly have of being able to xlog their wife or husband or whatever else - after 4 hours, they should be able to participate in the wave or whatever. It's still a huge disadvantage at that rate IMO, but I think that would be a compromise. At 72 hours you might as well say that couples/siblings/ect people shouldn't play in the same KD, period. And again, the reason I think 4 hours is reasonable, but yet still a disadvantage is a competitive KD can get anything they need from another KD mate in WELL UNDER 4 hours.

    ***edited for clarity
    Last edited by lirath; 04-12-2011 at 17:58.

  9. #384
    Regular
    Join Date
    Dec 2011
    Posts
    55
    Normal = 3 days
    Unfriendly = 2 days
    Hostile = 1 day
    War = 12 hours?

    This would be more doable but still a problem in hostile and wars. A 24 hour period where you can't do ops in Hostile is a lot.

    Now if you went this way:

    Normal=3 days
    Unfriendly= 1 day
    Hostile= 12 hours
    War=6 hours

    You might actually have something you can work around in a war. The current system is a total sham for players that did everything they were asked to do and play by the rules.

    The aid thing also must be fixed. If I select a province by accident and send aid, it can't just disappear. Give a warning or something instead of the Access Denied so the aid isn't destroyed.

  10. #385
    Forum Fanatic Darkz Azn's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2008
    Location
    NYC | Sanctuary
    Posts
    2,266
    the whole aid thingy is funny ...

    There was a tactic ... back than to mask-aiding ... to hide your true destination of either the solds pool or gc pool to either mass aid or solds bounce ...

    this pretty much neglect that tactic.... lolll =)


    Odd of Absalom

    Beastblood is #oddplay


    ˙ppo ǝɹɐ noʎ
    #odd
    Odd is a three-edged sword.
    ( ͡? ͜ʖ ͡?)

  11. #386
    Post Fiend
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Posts
    109
    Quote Originally Posted by Palem View Post
    @Nuriho - Cheaters are deleted. Have you been deleted? Then you're not a cheater.

    @ Shadow27 - I agree, the time frame on the block makes or breaks this system and I agree that 3 days is too long. Luckily the devs aren't blind, deaf, and dumb to the community (despite what you may hear) and are open to suggestions on how to make it work. I've already put forth my suggestion but I haven't seen too many people follow suit.


    This is incorrect and has already been discussed/explained by Bishop, DHaran, and myself.


    Quote Originally Posted by Palem View Post
    @Nuriho - Cheaters are deleted. Have you been deleted? Then you're not a cheater.

    @ Shadow27 - I agree, the time frame on the block makes or breaks this system and I agree that 3 days is too long. Luckily the devs aren't blind, deaf, and dumb to the community (despite what you may hear) and are open to suggestions on how to make it work. I've already put forth my suggestion but I haven't seen too many people follow suit.


    This is incorrect and has already been discussed/explained by Bishop, DHaran, and myself.
    Being a fairly new player coming over from Earth2025...this system SUCKS! Not to mention you are incorrect. When Mehul owned it you could get white listed on Earth because we did it. If you call what DHaran says as "discussed" you need to get a clue. He and a few others have their noses so far up Bishops backside its laughable. I read this entire thread and he is nothing but a "Richard Cranium", condescending and arrogant. If he worked for me, he wouldn't for long due to the fact his people skills SUCK!

    As far as the new "catching cheaters" program...I want to you know this will cost you the honest players and leave you with all the cheaters. Normally, the cheaters don't pay for anything because they are cheaters and circumvent the system. So, if you can honestly say that whitelisting is costly and time consuming just wait til you lose the money from the honest players and see what costs more. There have been a few questions asked here that were NEVER answered
    The one I never saw answered was...

    "Why in the middle of an age?" That's about dumb as hell to implement something half way thru.

    I have more to say but I think I better stop because I can pick apart tons of things wrong with this new "catch all". It just seems you are trying to drive people from the game and doing exactly what Bishop(devs and others) said they would never do and turning it into a "Pay to Win" game. Sorry if I wanted to do that I could go buy a character from WoW.

  12. #387
    Dear Friend Korp's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    8,846
    When Mehul owned it you could get white listed on Earth because we did it.
    Are you retarded? You are trying to say its incorrect by saying you could do it in a totally different game? Well, obviously you have no clue about Utopia, no you couldnt get whitelisted in Utopia. And on another note, how can you be fairly new if you are coming over from Earht cause Earth was shut down quite some time ago.

    you need to get a clue.
    I wouldnt throw stones in a glasshouse if i were you.

    I want to you know this will cost you the honest players and leave you with all the cheaters.
    Cause all the honest players has a partner they play with? Or they have several "friends" who they share IP with, in fact this wont effect most people at all, they will go on with their daily utopia business as nothing ever happend.


    You could keep on trying to make stupid points, but you would still look as dumb. Cause you havent had one coherent point so far.

  13. #388
    Moderator for:
    Utopia Forums
    Palem's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    22,030
    Could someone please explain to me how this system turns the game into pay-to-win?

  14. #389
    Post Fiend
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Posts
    109
    Quote Originally Posted by Korp View Post
    Are you retarded? You are trying to say its incorrect by saying you could do it in a totally different game? Well, obviously you have no clue about Utopia, no you couldnt get whitelisted in Utopia. And on another note, how can you be fairly new if you are coming over from Earht cause Earth was shut down quite some time ago.



    I wouldnt throw stones in a glasshouse if i were you.



    Cause all the honest players has a partner they play with? Or they have several "friends" who they share IP with, in fact this wont effect most people at all, they will go on with their daily utopia business as nothing ever happend.


    You could keep on trying to make stupid points, but you would still look as dumb. Cause you havent had one coherent point so far.


    Obviously YOU are the idiot because Earth is running. What are you about 19? Yeah, thats what I thought I wasn't addressing you and you stick your nose in where it doesnt belong. Typical. STFU and let the grown people talk.

  15. #390
    Dear Friend Korp's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    8,846
    Certainly Palem!

    This only the first step, soon they will implent certain features that makes "cheating" legal, ie letting two people in the same household interact, its all a very devious plan. Then they will keep adding things till its unpossible to win if you dont pay for it!

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •