Quote Originally Posted by MorbidAngel View Post
S1: so, according to you stoffi, say we wave one hall kd that doesn't retal us and sends cf. It is perfectly valid for 2nd hall kd to wave us one minute after cf was sent, even if our wave is not done (i said hall, but it can be abs or w/e u like, I really don't like that KD ABC thing as it confuses me :p). So, we send cf to that 2nd kd and we get waved by 3rd kd. Perfectly valid according to you, as hostile stops when one side sends cf.

S2: we wave one hall kd, they send cf. 2nd hall kd waves us, we want to declare them, but our armies are home so we wait. 8 hours pass w/o exchanging hits as both kd troops are still out, so it is valid for 3rd hall kd to wave us hour be4 we declare..

Fix your logic plz

Scenario 1:

It's not an active hostile and you are free for all to grab.

Scenario 2:

In theory, yes. You say your armies are home, I am assuming you mean out.




Scenario 2 is something I would not approve of. You can't follow the rules blindly.
but how can another kd know if it's an active hostile or not? How can ppl know if you are declaring or not? You might aswell have agreed with the other kd not to hit them, how can other kds know this? They CE you, and can't know what you are thinking.

This is shady territory. Since HaLL kds would talk together, Scenario 2 would never happen. It's not realistic.

However, if you exchange that 3rd kd with some other kd, like ABS or sinners or whatever, they could in theory wave.

But what are the odds of a kd planning to wave you on the exact date you CF another kd, and then another kd waving you exactly 9 hours after you waved AND got waved?
This is not a realistic scenario.


Scenario 1 however, is perfectly fine in my book. Though very few kds could produce a full wave within 30 minutes.