Japanese whaling

[Korp]

I was going away so i wouldnt have minded a ban :P

[stoffi]

I Ive asked in several posts where it says that yet you cant be arsed to explain that which leads me to think that you dont have any proof of it. Otherwise you could have ended this discussion one post after my question yet you havent, you just keep writing same **** over and over again, much alike what scorpio86 does.

And I've told you where to find it several times now.... Are you being stupid on purpose or just trolling?


Anyways, done discussing with a troll. You can read what I've written, 9/10 whales, no chopping up alive whales and grenade harpoons for the japanese and I've already said multiple times where you can read about it. Been saying and pointing for quite some time now, it's not my fault that you want to keep trolling.

For the future, keep the discussion simple, admit mistakes, read what people write, don't argue for the sake of arguing, don't troll.

[Korp]

No you havent you just replied with the same sentence again and again as if it was a mantra.

Ive already replied to those points but you just chose to ignore them and try to claim i said things i havent otherwise you would have already quoted where i said what you claim i did.

Your posting in here is rather cute to begin, starting to talk about norwegian whaling when the topic is japanese whaling those two are quite different in alot of ways. But i guess you are the kind of person that starts to talk about Mazda whe the topic is BMW.

[meanvj]

whaling is meh...

I'm from Aus, people don't really care. But the Japs aren't allowed to fish in Australian Territorial Waters.

The ISSUE is that the greenies claim that Australia's portion of Antarctica amounts to 'Australian Territorial Waters'...which it doesn't due tot he Antarctic Treaty etc etc etc.

Sea Shepherd = Fail
Paul Watson = Douche
Whales = Meat (not that anyone actually eats them)

Japan has the right to hunt whatever they like in international waters as long as there are no treaties etc etc etc that bind Japan.

[scorpio86]

The ISSUES are many.

Not all whales die instantly and some are still alive when dragged from the water and cut apart. Japan can hunt whatever they like as long as they don't breach other countrie's territory, yet they are lying to the world and saying that what they are doing is scientific research - when i sincerely doubt that it is. If they are doing it for a serious food source then perhaps the money and effort would be better spend in creating and operating fish farms inside their own waters.

I am from Australia and a lot of people do care indeed. At least Greenpeace and the people involved in this latest 'excitement' are brave enough to fight for what they beleive in, rather than spamming forums on the internet with opinions like all the rest of us.

There is nothing wrong with trolls, i find the term trolling offensive to trolls as trolls are in fact good creatures. Although they aren't real.

[stoffi]

No you havent you just replied with the same sentence again and again as if it was a mantra.

Ive already replied to those points but you just chose to ignore them and try to claim i said things i havent otherwise you would have already quoted where i said what you claim i did.

Your posting in here is rather cute to begin, starting to talk about norwegian whaling when the topic is japanese whaling those two are quite different in alot of ways. But i guess you are the kind of person that starts to talk about Mazda whe the topic is BMW.

How well do you understand English? Can you read? If yes, you are just trolling. If no, I understand.

It is not my fault that you can't read what's written on internet pages which I've already posted and even quoted in this very thread. I'm done dicussing with trolls.

[stoffi]

The ISSUES are many.

Not all whales die instantly and some are still alive when dragged from the water and cut apart.

This sentence is very problematic. Not even whale protection fanatics claim this, they claim the living whales are either shot twice or drowned slowly at the side of the ship. They do not mention whales being dragged onboard alive to be chopped up, which I'm sure they would mention if it happened... Perhaps you got some proof of your claim? Until then, both Greenpeace and Japan seem to disagree with you on this issue.

As for trolls not being real, I trust you haven't paid attention to Korp or THIS documentary then: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vy2nAOdBUlw

[scorpio86]

Your trust that i haven't paid attention to Korp or the documentary is very well placed.

[meanvj]

lets say the whales are alive when they're cut up....

i dont' care.

[scorpio86]

If you don't care then why post?

I say that at least some of them aren't.

[stoffi]

If you don't care then why post?

I say that at least some of them aren't.

Can you please point to a single source of documentation that says whales are being chopped up alive? You can't, because this is all in your head! You're accusing people of doing something they don't do! People go to jail for that sh*t!

[scorpio86]

I have seen footage of it on the evening Australian news, i have no documentation, simply an opinion.

[scorpio86]

Why the heck does everybody instantly click the qoute button, there is no need. My post was immediately above your own.

What is with that?

[stoffi]

I have seen footage of it on the evening Australian news, i have no documentation, simply an opinion.

Claiming that the Japanese cut up whales while still alive is not an opinion, it's a statement, just like claiming grass is blue or green. Saying grass is green is not an opinion, it's a statement referring to fact. It's got nothing to do with opinions. Learn your language. :)
If someone proves to you that a house has 2 floors(by showing you a photograph or taking you there), you don't get to have an opinion that the house contains 3 floors. It's just not possible.


How handy, you got no documentation and even greenpeace disagrees with you.... Whales are NOT cut up while still alive.


Btw, it is quite normal to quote posts in order to avoid confusion and so that you don't have to scroll up and down while you're reading what you originally wrote. I would advice you to quote as often as possible or you'll end up confusing a lot of people.

[RoseRedAus]

whaling is meh...

I'm from Aus, people don't really care. But the Japs aren't allowed to fish in Australian Territorial Waters.

The ISSUE is that the greenies claim that Australia's portion of Antarctica amounts to 'Australian Territorial Waters'...which it doesn't due tot he Antarctic Treaty etc etc etc.

Sea Shepherd = Fail
Paul Watson = Douche
Whales = Meat (not that anyone actually eats them)

Japan has the right to hunt whatever they like in international waters as long as there are no treaties etc etc etc that bind Japan.

Im an Aussie ... and I care.