Quote Originally Posted by tetley View Post
I think godly is correct in some ways that knowledge about the game is cumulative and evolving etc. Having played for 10 years instead of 2 years would extend an advantage to the top players still playing, in terms of strategy and general skill/experience in running a province optimally. Plus, familiarity with all mechanics would be relevant as well, to avoid having to re-learn the game.

That said, everyone I've ever spoken to about Sid has said that he was the nut in terms of leadership, one of the best players ever, etc., and this has to count for something.
Given the new anti cheating detection
Current technology to make the game more accessible
Accumulated skill over the last several years

The game is totally different then it was 8 years ago. CR/AMA would likely easily beat any kd from 2002. If they had to do it with tech from 2002 i think they would lose (unless of course munk just reopened umunk for his kd). Just attacking in/out for a week straight was extremely hard when you couldn't do it via your phone.

Although strategy was hugely important sheer activity was hard to beat back then.