I just have a few questions. Yes I'm in HoH so blah blah bias..
If Simian's didnt hit us and replied to Sanct's hits with a wave as an intent to war, HoH would never have hit back. If you think we are stupid enough to pump in preparation for Simian's wave, then eat a free wave you really don't know how to play this game very well. At the time of Sanctuary hitting simians bank and declaring intentions and sending a dragon did we hit them? Once we did wave Simians did Sanct keep attacking? Last question, if your target kd was in fort and you intended to war them, would you full wave them in fortified and give them the button so they can rape you once they press it?
In a ghetto example, forgetting the big names involved:
KD 2 notices KD 1 and 3 that they will wave.
KD 1 gets a few hits on KD 2 waiting for them to go out of fort until they full wave.
KD 2 decides to wave KD 3 despite intentions, a dragon, a bank hit and a promise to wave once fort is up from KD 1.
KD 1 waves KD 2.
KD 3 says, hell we aren't giving them a free wave and builds hostilities with a few hits then presses button.
If this was an every day occurrence between 3 random kingdoms KD 2 would just be like, oh well that didn't turn out very well, stupid move on our part... and then move on. The rest of the uto world would continue to rotate in a clockwise direction, the toilets would still flush differently in Australia and Michael Jackson would still be dead.
Last edited by jamin; 23-07-2012 at 20:21. Reason: sorry slight correction on KD 1 2 3 scenario
Final Fantasy XIV A Realm Reborn
Epic White Mage
Man, I finally read all of this. I took the weekend off for a wedding so a lot to read.
Seems to me Sanctuary and Rage started a dragon, this showed a clear intent to war.
Simians cleared up Rage so that only 1 KD would be warring them. They should have been ready to war sanctuary.
When CF terms ended Sanctuary made hits on Simians, it seems simians at this point failed to diplo a CF with sanctuary and should have started retaliating or continued training to get ready for the conflict.
Instead simians waved another KD. At this point Sanctuary has already invested in a dragon, and made some hits on you. Personally if I was dorje depending on how much free land I had taken I might have been willing to leave simians alone until after their war with HoH in exchange for 1 free wave. But really imo they could have kept hitting without any real issue simians choose to run from them without arranging a cf. When there is only 2-3 targets a dragon and a few hits should be enough to count as a hostile especially if you tell them you will give the button when they leave fortified.
Anri you have failed in my mind. Few will ever look back at this as anything but you miss judging a situation...
My life is better then yours.
Come on Palem, that's a pretty big exaggeration isn't it? I had a discussion with you about the situation, and I give you permission to post it here for viewing if you like, but it was a pretty reasonable talk wasn't it? Did "the alliance" touch you after you continued opping sanc into their hostile? As far as I know, there was no alliance involvement and you and I just had a two-way discussion about why you felt you needed to op them into the hostile.
There's no such logic, since when do newbies deserve any more chance to crown? Which sport in the world has that nonsensical rule? You already saw my earlier explanation. If Simians didn't want this **** then they shouldn't have noticed sanctuary, simple. U poke the bear now u get mauled and cry wtf is this rubbish.
Sorry I really don't get this, can you show me threads where abs have cried foul recently? I can pull a bunch of stupid threads by Anri and maybe some by Proteus but do you have any threads of abs crying so I can review it. Let's just give this an objective view, statement followed by evidence.
It was a double hostile that only ghettos normally get themselves in. Sometimes low level KD's get into a conflict and dont CF. Why simians thought they should get into a conflict then hit a different KD while still involved in that conflict is beyond me but yea... its just baffling. I think either sanctuary or hoh should have offered anri an immediate CF in return for a free wave after the war but I am unsure if anri would have even accepted...
My life is better then yours.
The only logical explanation was that they would could cry double hostile when they had no chance of winning anything. I've looked at their builds and setup and I don't think they would have been able to withstand any of the top 3 kd's. Their survey in itself is hilarious.
Hey, I had a nice, mostly pleasant chat (given the circumstances) with you and even Drixx previously on the matter. I have no problem with Rage. But you did make it very clear to me that what we were doing would typically cause the alliance to respond, even after I said a few times that getting abs involved would be a bad move. But you never DID say that abs wasn't going to step in on account of Sanc because you said you would get back to me and never did :(. On top of that, Sanc leadership got a hold of me the next day and was quickly resolved so there may have just not been enough time for Rage get switched around and start razing, or whatever they would have tried to do.
So yes, rage didn't get involved but for all I know that could be attributed to many other things aside from deciding that you shouldn't. That said, I do appreciate Rage's non-involvement :)
The fact does certainly remain though. We did something similar to Sanc and they immediately cried to their allies about it.
You miss my logic. Its not about gave mercy to Simians because they are newbie. Sanctuary is good enough to war/beat simians/most kds in fair fight 1vs1. I I'm sure HoH wanted fair 1vs1 war too.
In every sport win matter only if you get it fair. Simians idea was in general correct and good but they didn't make it proper. Its because they are for first time in top land chart position. For this blame them so hard is not objective. Sure Sanctuary have his good reason to insist Simians to war with them, but when you see its wont happen most honorable is to back off and let Simians to have his fair 1vs1 war with hoh. Sanc simple used Simians mistake to make his Double Hostile semy-legit. Nor Sanc/hoh/simians win from it in long term.
if that is the case then Anri did a huge mistake by overestimating his kingdom and/or underestimating their opponents. it makes sense then that when he saw sanctuary's setup and realised he'd be owned, his best move was to put himself in a position from where he could either avoid sanc or cry double hostile later and thus justify his failure. tho i doubt he can blame sanctuary for the farmage HoH is giving him now.
Sure his post remind me age 51 and rage :)
I agree you need to CF one kd before move to other conflict. Its basic knowledge. From other side its was used many times from ghetto to run from one kd with make hostile/war with another. And first kd still keep feed for free. Look like this age TOP was turned to real regular ghetto play.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)